Got a denial letter for unemployment, what now? - 13 weeks in

I got a denial letter last week saying I left my job voluntarily, but I was let go as a project coordinator. I am in Milwaukee, in case local advice matters. My employer's version of events does not match mine, and I have emails that show it. If you have appealed before, what helped you prepare?

I printed my emails in order and wrote a one-page timeline. The hearing officer kept going back to it.